Skip to main content
File #: AZB-24-122    Version: 1 Name: Appeal to Heron Creek Parcel K Development Order (Lobeck)
Type: Petition Status: Agenda Ready
File created: 10/4/2024 In control: Zoning Board of Appeals
On agenda: 12/16/2024 Final action: 12/16/2024
Title: Consideration of Petition AZB-24-122, Appeal to Development Order Issuance for Heron Creek-Parcel K Multi-Family Project (Major Site and Development Plan Approval MAS-23-160) (Lobeck) (QUASI-JUDICIAL)
Attachments: 1. 01 - Application to Request Appeal to MAS-23-160 (1).pdf, 2. 02 - Affected Aggrieved Person Status, 3. 03 - Heron Creek Associates Response to Appeal, 4. 04 - Affidavit of James L. Bevillard, 5. 05 - Affidavit of Ronald A. York, 6. 06 - DS Memo Residential Entitlements, 7. 07 - BMO Letter Comprehensive Plan Amendment, 8. 08 - N. Fossick Letter, 9. 09 - M. Roberts Memo - Analyze - Parcel K - Heron Creek, 10. 10 - Summary Judgment, 11. 11 - Ordinances, 12. 12 - Marsh Creek Questionnaire Checklist, 13. 13 - Correspondence from DCA, 14. 14 - BMO Letter Land Use Conversion Table, 15. 15 - Comprehensive Plan 1988-1998, 16. 16 - Comprehensive Plan 11-10-97 and amended, 17. 17 - Comprehensive Plan 6-27-17, 18. 18 - Applicants Calculations, 19. 19 - Staff calculations, 20. 20 - Notice of Representation, 21. 21 - Heron Creek Associates, Ltd. Amended Response to Appeal, 22. 22 - Revised Request for Affected Aggrieved Person Status, 23. 23 - Parcel K TIS (12-6-23)-Signed and Sealed.pdf, 24. 24 - Heron Creek Pattern Book.pdf, 25. Notice of Representation, 26. Notice of Representation, 27. Notice of Representation, 28. Additional Documents, 29. Joint Exhibit List (BMO), 30. 1. Appeal Petition AZB-24-122 (BMO), 31. 2. Application to Request Appeal to MAS-23-160 Affected Aggrieved Person Status (BMO), 32. 3. Heron Creek Associates Response to Appeal (BMO), 33. 4. Affidavit of James L. Bevillard (BMO), 34. 5. Affidavit of Ronald A. York (BMO), 35. 6. DS Memo Residential Entitlements (BMO), 36. 7. BMO Letter Comprehensive Plan Amendment (BMO), 37. 8. N. Fossick Letter (BMO), 38. 9. M. Roberts Memo - Analyze - Parcel K - Heron Creek (BMO), 39. 10. Order on Motion for Partial Summary Judgment in Case No. 2020 CA 4364 NC (BMO), 40. 11. DRI Ordinances (BMO), 41. 12. Marsh Creek Questionnaire Checklist (BMO), 42. 13. Correspondence from DCA (BMO), 43. 14. BMO Letter re Land Use Conversion Table 10-15-2021 (BMO), 44. 15. Comprehensive Plan 1988-1998 (BMO), 45. 16. Comprehensive Plan 11-10-97 and amended (BMO), 46. 17. Comprehensive Plan 6-27-17 (BMO), 47. 18. Applicants’ Calculations (BMO), 48. 19. Staff Calculations (BMO), 49. 20. Notice of Representation – Bryant Miller Olive P.A. (BMO), 50. 21. Heron Creek Associates, Ltd. Amended Response to Appeal (BMO), 51. 22. Revised Request for Affected Aggrieved Person Status (Heron Creek Assocs, Ltd.) (BMO), 52. 23. Parcel K Traffic Impact Statement (12-6-23)-Signed and Sealed (BMO), 53. 24. Heron Creek Pattern Book (BMO), 54. 25. Notice of Representation – Morgan (BMO), 55. 26. Notice of Representation – Neiberger (BMO), 56. 27. Notice of Representation – Brej (BMO), 57. 28. City Staff PowerPoint for 12-16-24 Hearing (BMO), 58. 29. Heron Creek Associates, Ltd. PowerPoint for 12-16-24 Hearing (BMO).pptx, 59. 30. Map H (original approved by Ord. 2000-13, and revised approved by Ord. 2011-33) (BMO), 60. 31. 5-30-24 Letter from A. Ray to C. Bailey re Extension Date for Buildout for Phase IV (BMO), 61. 32. 1-25-23 Letter from R. York to L. Barnes re Revised Modification of Land Use Table (BMO), 62. 33. 1999 Declaration of Covenants and Restrictions for Heron Creek (BMO), 63. 34. ITE Trip Generation Manual, 11th Edition, Publication Info (BMO)
Date Ver.Action ByActionResultAction DetailsMeeting DetailsVideo
12/16/20241 Zoning Board of Appeals    Not available Meeting details Video Video
12/16/20241 Zoning Board of Appeals    Not available Meeting details Video Video
12/16/20241 Zoning Board of Appeals    Not available Meeting details Video Video
12/16/20241 Zoning Board of Appeals    Not available Meeting details Video Video
12/16/20241 Zoning Board of Appeals    Not available Meeting details Video Video
12/16/20241 Zoning Board of Appeals    Not available Meeting details Video Video
12/16/20241 Zoning Board of Appeals    Not available Meeting details Video Video
12/16/20241 Zoning Board of Appeals    Not available Meeting details Video Video
12/16/20241 Zoning Board of Appeals    Not available Meeting details Video Video
12/16/20241 Zoning Board of Appeals    Not available Meeting details Video Video
12/16/20241 Zoning Board of Appeals    Not available Meeting details Video Video
12/16/20241 Zoning Board of Appeals    Not available Meeting details Video Video
12/16/20241 Zoning Board of Appeals    Not available Meeting details Video Video
12/16/20241 Zoning Board of Appeals    Not available Meeting details Video Video
12/16/20241 Zoning Board of Appeals    Not available Meeting details Video Video
12/16/20241 Zoning Board of Appeals    Not available Meeting details Video Video
12/16/20241 Zoning Board of Appeals    Not available Meeting details Video Video
12/16/20241 Zoning Board of Appeals    Not available Meeting details Video Video
12/16/20241 Zoning Board of Appeals    Not available Meeting details Video Video
12/16/20241 Zoning Board of Appeals    Not available Meeting details Video Video
12/16/20241 Zoning Board of Appeals    Not available Meeting details Video Video
12/16/20241 Zoning Board of Appeals    Not available Meeting details Video Video
12/16/20241 Zoning Board of Appeals    Not available Meeting details Video Video
12/16/20241 Zoning Board of Appeals    Not available Meeting details Video Video
12/16/20241 Zoning Board of Appeals    Not available Meeting details Video Video
12/16/20241 Zoning Board of Appeals    Not available Meeting details Video Video
12/16/20241 Zoning Board of Appeals    Not available Meeting details Video Video
12/16/20241 Zoning Board of Appeals    Not available Meeting details Video Video
12/16/20241 Zoning Board of Appeals    Not available Meeting details Video Video
12/16/20241 Zoning Board of Appeals    Not available Meeting details Video Video
12/16/20241 Zoning Board of Appeals    Not available Meeting details Video Video
12/16/20241 Zoning Board of Appeals    Not available Meeting details Video Video
12/16/20241 Zoning Board of Appeals    Not available Meeting details Video Video
12/16/20241 Zoning Board of Appeals    Not available Meeting details Video Video
12/16/20241 Zoning Board of Appeals    Not available Meeting details Video Video
12/16/20241 Zoning Board of Appeals    Not available Meeting details Video Video
12/16/20241 Zoning Board of Appeals    Not available Meeting details Video Video

TO:                                          Zoning Board of Appeals/Zoning Hearing Officer

 

FROM:                     Lori Barnes, AICP, CPM, Assistant Director, Development Services

 

SUBJECT                     Consideration of Petition AZB-24-122, Appeal to Development Order Issuance for Heron Creek-Parcel K Multi-Family Project (Major Site and Development Plan Approval MAS-23-160) (QUASI-JUDICIAL)

____________________________________________________________________________

 

Recommended Action

 

Uphold the Development Order issued for Heron Creek-Parcel K Multi-Family Project MAS-23-160.

 

General Information

 

The proposed Heron Creek-Parcel K development is a 150-unit multi-family development located on approximately 9.79 acres within the Heron Creek Development of Regional Impact. The proposed project was reviewed by the City’s Site Development Reviewers pursuant to Chapter 33, Article II, Section 33-8 of the North Port Unified Land Development Code. As part of this review, the Planning & Zoning Division staff determined the project is consistent with the North Port Comprehensive Plan, the Heron Creek Development of Regional Impact Development Order, Ordinance No. 2000-13, as amended, and all applicable provisions of the Unified Land Development Code. On June 18, 2024, the Planning & Zoning Division of the North Port Development Services Department approved and issued a development order for the referenced project, as authorized by Section 33-8.D.(4) of the ULDC.

 

On July 18, 2024, Daniel J. Lobeck, Esq. filed an Application to Request an Appeal on behalf of Heron Creek Community Association, Inc. The submittal indicated an appeal to the June 18, 2024, Development Services staff approval of Development Order issued for Heron Creek-Parcel K Multi-Family Project (Major Site and Development Plan Approval MAS-23-160) under Article II, Sections 1-10.A(2) and 1-10.C. of the North Port Unified Land Development.

 

 

Attachments:                      

 

1.                     Application to Request an Appeal with Supporting Documents

2.                     Heron Creek Associates, Ltd. Request for Affected/Aggrieved Person Status with Adversely Affected Explanation

3.                     Heron Creek Associates, Ltd. Response to Appeal of MAS-23-160 by Heron Creek Community Association, Inc.

4.                     Affidavit of James L. Bevillard

5.                     Affidavit of Ronald A. York

6.                     Development Services Department Memo regarding Heron Creek Residential Entitlements Under the Development of Regional Impact & Neighborhood Meeting Requirements dated October 2, 2023

7.                     Bryant, Miller, Olive Response to Legal Request regarding Necessity of Comprehensive Plan Amendment dated January 3, 2024

8.                     Letter from Noah Fossick to Matt Morris regarding requirements for Heron Creek Parcel K dated May 30, 2023

9.                     Interoffice Memorandum From Margaret Roberts to A. Jerome Fletcher II, regarding Analyze Parcel K Issue - Heron Creek, dated January 20, 2022

10.                     Order on Defendants/Counterclaim Plaintiffs’ Amended Motion for Partial Final Summary Judgment on Counter-Claim and Cross-Claim, in Heron Creek Associates, Ltd. V. Steve Dsupin, et al (Case No. 2020 CA 4364 NC)

11.                     Ordinances 2000-13 with Map H, 2005-28, 2006-46, 2011-33 with Map H, 2013-16;

12.                     Marsh Creek Questionnaire Checklist for DRI ADA Submission

13.                     Multiple correspondence from Department of Community Affairs in 1996,1997, 2001

14.                     BMO’s Letter regarding Heron Creek Land use and Conversion Table dated October 15, 2021;

15.                     Comprehensive Plan 1988-1998, adopted March 15, 1989

16.                     Comprehensive Plan, adopted November 10, 1997, amended July 1999, and amended May 28, 2002 (this was provided as one document without detailed information of the revisions in 1999 and 2002).

17.                     Comprehensive Plan, adopted June 27, 2017

18.                     Applicant’s Calculations

19.                     Staff’s Calculations

20.                     Notice of Representation

21.                     Heron Creek Associates Amended Response to Appeal

22.                     Revised Request for Affected Aggrieved Person Status

23.                     Parcel K TIS (12-6-23)-Signed and Sealed

24.                     Heron Creek Pattern Book

 

 

Prepared by:                                                               Lori Barnes, AICP, CPM, Assistant Director, Development Services

 

Department Director:                     Alaina Ray, AICP, Development Services Director