A.
Consideration of Petition VAC-24-174 through Resolution No. 2025-R-13
Vacating the Platted 10-foot Utility and Drainage Easements For Lots 11,
12, 31 and 32 Block 1438, 29th Addition to Port Charlotte Subdivision.
(Quasi-Judicial)
Chair Waugh announced the item, stated this is a quasi-judicial hearing, and called on
the Board Specialist to read the petition title and swear in those wishing to provide
testimony.
Ms. Gray read the petition title and swore in those wishing to provide testimony.
Chair Waugh called for disclosure of ex-parte communications.
The Board disclosed no ex-parte communications.
Ms. Gray stated there were no aggrieved parties.
Mr. Brown, being duly sworn, provided a presentation including overview, background,
review process, compliance with Florida Statutes and Unified Land Development Code
(ULDC), staff recommendations, and survey of existing conditions.
There was no public comment.
Board questions and discussion took place regarding applicant availability, existing
conditions, utility approval, and drainage impacts.
Ms. Willette-Grondin, being duly sworn, responded to questions regarding drainage
impacts.
Board questions and discussion continued regarding inclusion of survey in backup,
vacating easements on all lots, Florida Statute requirements, unity of lots, septic tank
location, easement relocation, property value, location of pool, and continuing the item for
additional information.
Ms. Coughlin spoke to legal requirement to approve or deny the application.
Board questions and discussion continued regarding Board role, statutory requirements,
and process for approval/denial.
There were no closing arguments.
Chair Waugh closed the public hearing and requested a motion.
A motion was made by Vice Chair Ludos, seconded by Board Member Irizarry, to
recommend approval to the City Commission of Resolution No. 2025-R-13, as
presented. The motion failed on the following vote:
3 - Vice Chair Ludos, Board Member Irizarry and Board Member Patricoski
4 - Chair Waugh, Board Member Keogh, Alternate I Wolf and Board Member Baer
2 - Board Member Bagaev and Alternate II Gortz
Yes:
No:
Absent:
A motion was made by Board Member Baer, seconded by Board Member Wolf, to
recommend denial to the City Commission of Resolution No. 2025-R-13, as
presented. The motion carried on the following vote: