4970 CITY HALL BLVD

NORTH PORT, FL 34286

City of North Port

Meeting Minutes - Final

Code Enforcement Hearing

Thursday, March 24, 2022

9:00 AM

City Commission Chambers

1. CALL TO ORDER

Hearing Officer Toale called the meeting to order at 9:20 a.m.

Also Present

Assistant City Attorney Michael Golen, Code Enforcement Division Manager Kevin

Raducci, Code Enforcement Administrative Service Specialist Terri Hasker, Code

Enforcement Recording Secretary Michele Ross, Code Enforcement Inspectors Henley

Burton, Jeffrey Guilbault, Jennifer Ardinger, and William Kiddy, and Recording Secretary

Susan Hale.

2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE

The Pledge of Allegiance was led by Attorney Toale.

3. PUBLIC COMMENT

There was no public comment.

4. APPROVAL OF MINUTES

22-2412

Approval of Minutes for the February 24, 2022 Code Enforcement Hearing

Officer Meeting.

Hearing Officer Toale approved the Minutes as presented.

5. REVIEW OF PROCEDURES AND ADMINISTRATION OF OATH

Hearing Officer Toale provided an overview of procedures and Ms. Hale swore in all those

wishing to provide testimony.

6. COMPLIANT CASES

A. Case No

(HLB) Rade Nedeljkov, 8470 Drolet Ave

20-1736

Chapter 42-23, North Port City Code

(Debris consisting of a chair, concrete blocks on the left side of the

property and yard debris, boxes and trash on the ground on the right side of

property and also solid waste containers and properly stored in yard.)

Chapter 62-50, North Port City Code

(Solid Waste containers stored improperly in the front yard.)

This case was brought into compliance with no further action required.

B. Case No

(JA) Casey M & Kristina A Kelch, 2437 Baltimore St

Chapter 62-50, North Port City Code

21-3256

(Solid Waste Containers improperly stored at the curb outside the normal

pick-up day. Pick up for this area is on Tuesday. Violation observed on

Thursday.)

This case was brought into compliance with no further action required.

C. Case No

(WK) Petar Minic & Sasha Minich, 8337 Bumford Ave

Chapter 105.1, Florida Building Code

21-3268

(No permit on file for window change out in front of house.)

Sec. 1-19, Unified Land Development Code

(No permit on file for new fence installed on property)

This case was brought into compliance with no further action required.

D. Case No

(JAG) Efrain A Pacheco, 3116 Whiptree Cir.

21-3794

Sec. 59-16(f)(4), North Port City Code

(Three Tractor Trailers parked in City Right-of-way.)

Sec. 59-16(c), North Port City Code

(Multiple semi-trucks and tractor trailers parked on a vacant lot with no

principal structure.)

Sec. 1-19, Unified Land Development Code

(No permit on file for the fence that was installed on property.)

Sec. 59-16(F)(1), North Port City Code

(One "unlicensed Volkswagen Jetta, and one unlicensed box truck parked

in City Right-of-way, in front of a vacant lot. parked in front of a vacant lot)

Sec. 59-16(f)(3), North Port City Code

(Damage to the city right away from tractor trailers driving through the

vacant lot)

Sec. 59-16(f)(3), North Port City Code

(One "unlicensed Volkswagen Jetta, and one unlicensed box truck parked

in City Right-of-way, in front of a vacant lot. parked in front of a vacant lot)

This case was brought into compliance with no further action required.

E. Case No

(JA) Alejandra L Daniels, 3114 Tulsa Ave

21-4188

Sec. 59-16(f)(4), North Port City Code

(White trailer parked in City Right-of-way, in front of home.)

This case was brought into compliance with no further action required.

F. Case No

(JA) Sherry Lynn Marti, 8372 Larrimore Ave

Sec. 1-19, Unified Land Development Code

(No permit on file for fence located on property)

21-4882

This case was brought into compliance with no further action required.

G. Case No

(JA) Manuel R & Diana J & John J Andrade, 8050 Porto Chico Ave

Chapter 42-23, North Port City Code

21-4943

(Accumulation of debris consisting of chairs, wood, car parts, boxes,

plastic, and other miscellaneous debris in front of house and in driveway.)

Sec. 59-16(f)(4), North Port City Code

(Parking pop up camper and trailer parked in the City right of way in front of

house)

This case was brought into compliance with no further action required.

H. Case No

(JAG) Matthew A Lintz & Crystal Soto, 3086 Broad Ave

Chapter 70-56, North Port City Code

21-5035

(No visible assigned numbers affixed to residence.)

This case was brought into compliance with no further action required.

Case No

21-5037

(JAG) Steven F Martin, 3441 Alfred Rd

Chapter 62-50, North Port City Code

(Solid waste containers are being stored in the middle of the driveway and

in front of the front plane of the home.)

This case was brought into compliance with no further action required.

J. Case No

(HLB) Salvador A & Clemencia C Santos, 3493 S San Mateo Dr

Chapter 105.1, Florida Building Code

21-5090

(No Permit on file for a makeshift shed on the left rear corner of the

property)

This case was brought into compliance with no further action required.

K. Case No

(JAG) Robert & Teresa Newton & Domonick & Joanne Lobianco, 2343

Cincinnati St

21-5091

Chapter 66-62 (c), North Port City Code

(Downed portable basketball hoop in the City Right-of-way.)

This case was brought into compliance with no further action required.

L. Case No

(JAG) Mikhail & Nada Margitich, 3659 Weidman Ave

Chapter 62-50, North Port City Code

21-5115

(Solid waste containers at the street. Pick up in the area is on Tuesday.)

This case was brought into compliance with no further action required.

M. Case No

(JAG) DSB Land Trust, 2467 N Cranberry Blvd

21-5125

Section 42-24(a)(5) North Port City Code

(Accumulation of debris in the City Right-of-way consisting of yard waste,

TVs, a mattress, and other miscellaneous items)

This case was brought into compliance with no further action required.

N. Case No

(JAG) Jeffrey M & Joyce K Dales, 2808 Tusket Ave

21-5128

Chapter 62-50, North Port City Code

(Solid Waste Containers improperly stored at the street outside the time

frame permissible by City Code. Pick up for this area is on Tuesday,

violation observed on a Thursday)

This case was brought into compliance with no further action required.

O. Case No

(WK) CPI/Amherst SFR Program II Owner, 2558 Begonia Ter

Chapter 78-95, North Port City Code

21-5148

(Discharge of from water softener, erosion and salt run off pooling and

killing neighboring house grass @2522 Begonia Ter; break of PVC line on

side of home requiring fix.)

This case was brought into compliance with no further action required.

P. Case No

(JA) Anthony J & Jaseth J Mcfarlane, 2983 Cerullo St

Chapter 105.1, Florida Building Code

21-5150

(Permit required for house re-pipe. Please contact the Building

Department at 941-429-7044 for proper requirements.)

This case was brought into compliance with no further action required.

Q. Case No

(JAG) Fishtail Holdings LLC, 4071 Everglades Ter

Sec. 59-16(f)(4), North Port City Code

21-5178

(Jon boat being parked in City Right-of-way, in front of vacant lot, across

the street from residence.)

Sec. 59-16(f)(3), North Port City Code

(Jon boat being parked in City Right-of-way, in front of vacant lot, across

the street from residence.)

This case was brought into compliance with no further action required.

R. Case No

(JAG) Antonio Regueira, 2934 Wyola Ave

21-5196

Chapter 70-56, North Port City Code

(House numbers affixed to residence are not visible due to overgrowth of

vegetation. Please trim back vegetation or move assigned numbers to a

location where they are visible from the street.)

This case was brought into compliance with no further action required.

S. Case No

(JAG) Natalya Nickles, 5934 N Cranberry Blvd

21-5197

Chapter 62-50, North Port City Code

(Solid Waste Containers improperly stored at the street outside the time

frame permissible by City Code. Pick up for this area is on Tuesday,

violation observed on a Thursday.)

This case was brought into compliance with no further action required.

T. Case No

(HLB) Estero Development Partners LP, 2075 Ivor Ave

Chapter 42-23, North Port City Code

21-5209

(Construction site has accumulation of debris on property and right of way

consisting of construction materials and trash.)

This case was brought into compliance with no further action required.

U. Case No

(JA) Marjorie A Kelly Pena, 7788 Minardi St

Chapter 34-23, North Port City Code

21-5236

(Business (Yasmar Pavers) registered to this address with no business tax

on file.)

Sec. 59-16(f)(3), North Port City Code

(Dump truck belonging to this address parked down street in the city

right-of-way in front of a vacant lot.)

Sec. 59-16(i), North Port City Code

(Dump truck belonging to this address parked down street, not permitted in

residential area.)

Sec. 1-19, Unified Land Development Code

(Fence on this property, permit is in pickup status since March 16, 2021)

This case was brought into compliance with no further action required.

V. Case No

(HLB) Scraper Family Living Trust, James L & Stacy L Scraper TTEE,

2098 Roscoe Ln

21-5261

Chapter 105.1, Florida Building Code

(No Permit on file for the above ground pool in the backyard.)

This case was brought into compliance with no further action required.

W. Case No

(HLB) Beresford & Marva Gayle, 5321 Inkwood Dr

Chapter 42-23, North Port City Code

22-29

(Property owner has accumulation of debris on property consisting of

portable carport, camping materials, different types of fencing, trash and

other miscellaneous items)

Chapter 70-21, North Port City Code

(Driving over the City right of way to access this property)

This case was brought into compliance with no further action required.

X. Case No

(WK) Harry & Laura Klinkhamer, 1720 S Salford Blvd

Chapter 42-23, North Port City Code

22-34

(Debris consisting of wood fence in disrepair, posts and sections of the

fence falling into the rear neighbor’s yard. Fence is leaning on a tree,

broken slats lying in the yard.)

This case was brought into compliance with no further action required.

Y. Case No

(HLB) Jeffrey & Rachel Kirkus, 5331 Ceriman Rd

Section 45-5A, Unified Land Development Code

(No permit on file for land clearing.)

22-41

This case was brought into compliance with no further action required.

Z. Case No

(JA) Mateo Orlando Otano Malagon, & Maricela Ramon Rodriquez &

Orlando Otano Ramon, 4491 Lullaby Rd

22-44

Chapter 42-23, North Port City Code

(Debris consisting of two visible boat engines, an arc structure in rear left of

the property and yard waste in the back of an open trailer on the side of the

property.)

Sec. 53-122D, Unified Land Development Code

(Prohibited business being run from the residence, three large boats on the

property, a large wooden arc structure, large trailer, truck and two (2) boat

engines on the rear left of this property.)

This case was brought into compliance with no further action required.

AA. Case No

(PJM) H P Hallock Company C/O Ducharme, McMillen & Associates,

12600 S Tamiami Trail

22-170

Section 26-20, North Port City Code

(The fire sprinkler system has a yellow non-compliance tag indicating

NON-CRITICAL deficiencies. Non-critical deficiencies are to be corrected

within 90 days from the date of the inspection as outlined in

FAC 69A-46.041.)

This case was brought into compliance with no further action required.

AB. Case No

(JAG) Julissa Torres Santos, 6354 Freemont St

Chapter 42-23, North Port City Code

22-198

(Remove, or cause to be removed, any and all debris on said property

within ten (10) days from the date of this Notice.)

Section 42-24(a)(5) North Port City Code

(Accumulation of debris in City Right-of-way consisting of yard waste, and

other miscellaneous items.)

Sec. 59-16(e), North Port City Code

(Grey car blocking the sidewalk.)

Sec. 59-16(d), North Port City Code

(One black inoperable car on jack stands and uncovered in the driveway.

Must be covered with a non-transparent tarp)

This case was brought into compliance with no further action required.

AC. Case No

(JAG) Kusum LLC, 6358 Pan American Blvd

Chapter 70-56, North Port City Code

22-223

(No assigned numbers affixed to the residence.)

This case was brought into compliance with no further action required.

AD. Case No

(JAG) Jason J & Elizabeth M Wager, 5468 Cold Spring Ln

Chapter 42-23, North Port City Code

22-227

(Accumulation of debris consisting of dirt and sand, in the road in front of

the driveway at this property.)

This case was brought into compliance with no further action required.

AE. Case No

(JAG) Michael Lagerstrom, 8160 Lombra Ave

22-230

Sec. 59-16(f)(4), North Port City Code

(Prompt Towing Service truck and a white car parked in the city

right-of-way across the street from the residence at Hope Park.)

Sec. 59-16(f)(3), North Port City Code

(Damage to the City right-of-way and sidewalk.)

This case was brought into compliance with no further action required.

AF. Case No

(HLB) Jacob Harrold & Marianne Nowottny, 2817 Tusket Ave

Sec. 59-16(F)(1), North Port City Code

22-267

(Homeowner has un-registered vehicle with no tags in the City

Right-of-way, in front of residence.)

This case was brought into compliance with no further action required.

7. CONTINUED CASES

A. Case No

(JA) Maria A Carrasquillo, 8495 Cristobal Ave

Chapter 105.1, Florida Building Code

21-4864

(No permit on file for carport enclosure.)

Inspector Ardinger, being duly sworn, stated the property was inspected on multiple

occasions, submitted photos into evidence, and requested a continuance to May.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale continued Case No. 21-4864

8495 Cristobal Avenue to the May 26, 2022 Code Enforcement Hearing.

8. 1ST HEARING CASES

A. Case No.

(HLB) Ileana Smarandache, 8795 Cristobal Ave

21-2272

Sec. 1-19, Unified Land Development Code

(Aluminum fence installed on property with no permit.)

Inspector Burton, being duly sworn, stated the property was inspected on multiple

occasions, he had contact with the property owner, and submitted photos into evidence.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale found Case No. 21-2272 8795

Cristobal Avenue to be in violation of Section 1-19, Unified Land Development

Code for aluminum fence installed on property with no permit and imposed a fine

of $25 a day with a maximum of $2000 to commence on April 19, 2022.

B. Case No

(WK) Chad & Jaymi Brousseau, 2666 Calabash Ln

21-4602

Sec. 59-16(f)(3), North Port City Code

(Damage to Swale from Tire Ruts)

Chapter 70-21, North Port City Code

(Driving through City Right-of-way, causing damage.)

Sec. 53-239(I)(12), Home Occupations/Special Circumstances

(Outside storage of construction materials, pavers, and equipment.)

Chapter 105.1, Florida Building Code

(No permit on file for two accessory structures and deck on right side of

property. Permit also required for City Right-of-way work performed, and

two pipes installed, as well of rocks throughout. None of which is to code)

Chapter 42-23, North Port City Code

(Accumulation of debris consisting of loose trash, wood pallets, household

items, plastic buckets, tires, and other miscellaneous items that should be

stored within enclosed structure)

Inspector Kiddy, being duly sworn, stated the property was inspected on multiple

occasions and submitted photos into evidence.

Property owner Chad Brousseau, being duly sworn, stated he was unaware a permit was

needed, noted his intentions regarding the items to be removed, and requested guidance

concerning permits.

Mr. Kiddy spoke to permit processing for construction sites and suggested for Mr.

Brousseau to work with the Building Department regarding the shed.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale continued Case No. 21-4602

1141 Plant Terrace to the April 28, 2022 Code Enforcement Hearing.

C. Case No.

(WK) Wayne E & Donna J Scheiner & Jason F Erickson, 1141 Plant Ter

Chapter 70-21, North Port City Code

21-4829

(Driving through the City right of way with vehicles.)

Section 105.4.1.1, Florida Building Code

(Permit 18-7077 for window replacement expired February 18, 2019.)

Inspector Kiddy, being duly sworn, stated the property was inspected on multiple

occasions, the violation for Section 105.1.1, Florida Statutes came into compliance, and

requested a continuance for the violation of Chapter 70-21, North Port City Code.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale continued Case No. 21-4829

1141 Plant Terrace regarding Chapter 70-21, North Port City Code to the April 28,

2022 Code Enforcement Hearing.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale closed Case No. 21-4829 1141

Plant Terrace regarding Section 105.4.1.1, Florida Building Code due to

compliance with no further action required.

D. Case No

(WK) Domka & Alena Tarasenko, 5498 Densaw Rd

21-4986

Section 105.4.1.1, Florida Building Code

(Permit 18-4791 is expired for six (6) windows, and slider impact, needs to

be reactivated or revoked. Contact permitting for solution.)

Inspector Kiddy, being duly sworn, stated the property was inspected on multiple

occasions, he had contact with the property owners, and submitted photos into evidence.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale found Case No. 21-4986 498

Densaw Road to be in violation of Section 105.4.1.1, Florida Building Code for an

expired permit and imposed

commence on April 19, 2022.

a fine of $50 a day with a maximum of $5000 to

E. Case No

(WK) Bao Liang & Mei Zhu Chen, 2550 Blackbird Ln

Chapter 42-23, North Port City Code

21-5020

(Debris consisting loose trash spilling out from containers and on right side

of driveway in yard)

Chapter 62-50, North Port City Code

(Solid Waste Containers stored in front of residence on the driveway.)

This case was brought into compliance with no further action required.

F. Case No

(JAG) Keith W & Lori A Lamb, 2154 Azure Rd

Section 105.4.1.1, Florida Building Code

21-5043

(Permit numbers 19-7602 for a Single-Family Residence & 19-7868 for a

Garage have expired)

Inspector Guilbault, being duly sworn, noted the property owner is working on obtaining a

permit, and he requested a 90-day continuance.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale continued Case No. 21-5043

2154 Azure Road to the August 25, 2022 Code Enforcement Hearing.

G. Case No

(WK) Peter Mezheritsky & Yelena Levontin, 3344 Needle Ter

Chapter 42-23, North Port City Code

21-5059

(Accumulation of debris consisting of yard debris that was cut from palm in

front yard.)

Inspector Kiddy, being duly sworn, stated the property is in compliance.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale closed the Case No.21-5059

3344 Needle Terrace due to compliance with no further action required.

H. Case No

(HLB) Valeriy Kushnir, 2836 Abbeville Rd

21-5074

Sec. 59-16(i), North Port City Code

(White semi-truck parked in the City right of way in front of this property)

Inspector Burton, being duly sworn, noted the property owner is working to find a place to

park the truck, and he requested a continuance.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale continued Case No. 21-5074

2836 Abbeville Road to the April 28, 2022 Code Enforcement Hearing.

Case No

21-5084

(HLB) Kenneth N Carignan Jr, 3520 Johannesberg Rd

Chapter 42-23, North Port City Code

(Debris consisting of wooden fencing post around property.)

Sec. 1-19, Unified Land Development Code

(No Permit on file for the fence posts around this property.)

Inspector Burton, being duly sworn, stated the property was inspected on multiple

occasions, he had no contact with the property owner until today, submitted photos into

evidence, and spoke to the fence post panels being removed but wooden posts remain

standing.

Property owner Kenneth Carignan, being duly sworn, states he was unaware fence posts

were considered debris and was unsure when he could pull a permit.

Inspector Raducci, being duly sworn, addressed why posts are considered debris,

explained the permit application process, and why posts cannot remain without panels.

Inspector Ardinger, being duly sworn, stated posts having been present since February,

2021.

Mr. Toale spoke to a new owner being responsible for unpermitted work when the house

was bought, and he will only fine the Unified Land Development citation due to the two

violations being inconsistent with each other.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale dismissed Case No. 21-5084

3520 Johannesberg Road regarding Chapter 42-23, North Port City Code.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale found Case No. 21-5084 3520

Johannesberg Road in violation of Section 1-19, Unified Land Development Code

for no permit on file for the fence posts around this property and imposed a fine of

$10 a day with a maximum of $2000 to commence on April 19, 2022.

J. Case No

(JAG) Coelho Investments USA LLC, 4439 Eldron Ave

Section 45-5A, Unified Land Development Code

(No Permit on file for an underbrush clear that has occurred at this

property.)

21-5116

Inspector Guilbault, being duly sworn, stated the property was inspected on multiple

occasions, the number of trees removed was undetermined, and submitted photos into

evidence.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale, found Case No. 21-5116 4439

Eldron Avenue to be in violation of Section 45-5(a), Unified Land Development

Code for no permit on file for underbrush clearing with an unknown number of

trees being removed and imposed a fine of $2500.

K. Case No

(WK) Home SFR Borrower IV LLC, 5362 Trekell St

Chapter 42-23, North Port City Code

21-5141

(Accumulation of debris consisting of yard waste, trash, unused household

items piled up, boxes, and carpet.)

Section 105.4.1.1, Florida Building Code

(Expired permit 19-8875 on file, inspection required.)

Inspector Kiddy, being duly sworn, stated the property was inspected on multiple

occasions, he had no contact with the property owner, and the violation for Chapter

42-23, North Port City Code for an expired permit is now in compliance.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale closed Case No. 21-5141 5362

Trekell Street regarding Chapter 42-23, North Port City Code due to compliance

with no further action required.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale found Case No. 21-5141 5362

Trekell Street in violation of Section 105.4.1.1, Florida Building Code for expired

permit and imposed a fine of $50 a day with a maximum of $5000 to commence on

April 19, 2022.

L. Case No

(WK) Evelyn Y & Eduardo Javier Sedlar, 4461 Pocatella Ave

Sec. 59-16(c)(2), North Port City Code

21-5151

(Number of vehicles (12) on property exceeds which is permissible by City

Code for this property size)

Sec. 53-122D, Unified Land Development Code

(Active Lawn Service Business being ran from home with parking and

storage of commercial vehicles, trailers, and material storage)

Chapter 42-23, North Port City Code

(Accumulation of debris consisting of wood, stone, pavers, concrete

blocks, and lawn mower parts.)

Sec. 59-16(f)(4), North Port City Code

(Trucks and Trailers parked in City Right-of-way.)

Inspector Kiddy, being duly sworn, noted the property was inspected on multiple

occasions, he had contact with the property owner, and submitted photos into evidence.

Property owner Eduardo Sedlar, being duly sworn, agreed the photos were accurate and

stated he needed a few weeks to move equipment.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale found Case No. 21-5151 4461

Pocatella Avenue to be in violation of Section 59-16(c)(2), North Port City Code for

vehicles on property exceeding permissible number and imposed a fine of $10 a

day with a maximum of $1000 to commence on April 19, 2022.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale found Case No. 21-5151 4461

Pocatella Avenue to be in violation of Section 53-122(d), Unified Land Development

Code for doing a business from home with parking and storage of commercial

vehicles, trailers, and material storage and imposed a fine of $25 a day with a

maximum of $2000 to commence on April 19, 2022.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale found Case No. 21-5151 4461

Pocatella Avenue to be in violation of Chapter 42-23, North Port City Code for

accumulation of debris, and imposed a fine of $10 a day with a maximum of $1000

to commence on April 19, 2022.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale found Case No. 21-5151 4461

Pocatella Avenue to be in violation of Section 59-16(f)(4), North Port City Code for

trucks and trailers parked in City right-of-way, and imposed a fine of $10 a day with

a maximum of $1000 to commence on April 19, 2022.

M. Case No

(HLB) Christopher Roland Barber PMA, 7610 Cottagemaid St

Chapter 42-23, North Port City Code

21-5198

(Accumulation of debris on vacant lot consisting of miscellaneous items)

Sec. 59-16(c), North Port City Code

(Two (2) vehicles and trailer being parked on vacant lot with no principal

structure.)

Chapter 105.1, Florida Building Code

(Two (2) sheds located on vacant lot with no permit on file)

Sec. 59-16(h), North Port City Code, Living or Camping in Vehicles

(RV parked on vacant lot appears to be inhabited)

Inspector Burton, being duly sworn, stated the property was inspected on multiple

occasions, he had no contact with owner prior to today, submitted legal documents into

the record from the property owner and submitted photos into evidence.

Mr. Toale stated the property owner was not present and there was no evidence to

support any of the assertions in his affirmative defense.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale found Case No. 21-5198 7610

Cottage Main Street to be in violation of Chapter 42-23, North Port City Code for the

accumulation of debris on vacant lot and imposed a fine of $10 a day with

maximum of $1000 to commence on April 19, 2022.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale found Case No. 21-5198 7610

Cottage Main Street to be in violation of Section 59-16(c), North Port City Code for

vehicles and trailer being parked on vacant lot with no principal structure and

imposed a fine of $10 a day with a maximum of $1000 to commence on April 19,

2022.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale found Case No. 21-5198 7610

Cottage Main Street to be in violation of Chapter 105.1, Florida Building Code for

sheds located on vacant lot with no permit on file and imposed a fine of $50 a day

with a maximum of $5000 to commence on April 19, 2022.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale found Case No. 21-5198 7610

Cottage Main Street to be in violation of Section 59-16(h), North Port City Code for

RV parked on vacant lot which appears to be inhabited and imposed a fine of $10 a

day with a maximum of $1000 to commence on April 19, 2022.

N. Case No

(JA) Heather M Heyes, 1063 S Hartsdale St

21-5210

Chapter 42-23, North Port City Code

(Debris consisting of wheel barrel, gas containers, ladder, kitchen stove,

plastic containers, vehicle parts, kitchen sink, dead yard waste piles, and

other miscellaneous debris throughout property)

Sec. 59-16(f)(4), North Port City Code

(Boat parked in the City right of way in front of this property.)

Chapter 70-21, North Port City Code

(Driving through the City right of way via the vacant lot to the right of this

address not owned by this resident.)

Sec. 59-16(c)(5), North Port City Code

(RV parked in the easement of the vacant lot to the left not owned by this

resident)

This case was brought into compliance with no further action required.

O. Case No

(HLB) Adonys & Leonor Martinez, 2775 LaCasa Rd

Chapter 105.1, Florida Building Code

21-5268

(No Permit on file for the shed that is in the backyard of this property.)

Inspector Burton, being duly sworn, noted the property owner is actively obtaining a

permit, and he requested a continuance.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale continued Case No. 21-5268

2775 LaCasa Road to the April 28, 2022 Code Enforcement Hearing.

P. Case No

(JA) LSF10 Master Participation Trust, 8314 Drolet Ave

Sec. 59-16(i), North Port City Code

22-14

(Bucket truck parked in the driveway of this property.)

Inspector Burton, being duly sworn, noted the property owner never notified the tenant, is

in process finding a place to park the truck, and he requested a continuance.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale continued Case No. 22-14 8314

Drolet Avenue to the April 28, 2022 Code Enforcement Hearing.

Q. Case No

(HLB) Michael Gamble, 2972 Button St

Section 45-5A, Unified Land Development Code

(No permit on file for land clearing.)

22-22

Inspector Burton, being duly sworn, stated the property was inspected on multiple

occasions, he had no contact with the property owner prior to today, and submitted

photos into evidence.

Property owner Michael Gamble, being duly sworn, stated he was unaware a permit was

required, trees consisted of pine trees and palmetto scrub, he received violation by

chance finding it on the ground, and stated that approximately 20 trees were removed.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale found Case No. 22-22 2972

Button Street in violation of Section 45-5(a), Unified Land Development Code for no

permit on file for land clearing and imposed a fine of $2500.

R. Case No

(HLB) Ahmed Khamis, 2891 Chinabox St

Chapter 42-23, North Port City Code

22-27

(Debris consisting of pallets, camping materials, trash and other

miscellaneous items.)

Sec. 46-148 City of North Port Code

(Owner is camping on this vacant lot.)

Sec. 59-16(c), North Port City Code

(RV camper being stored on this property without a principal structure)

Inspector Burton, being duly sworn, stated the property was inspected on multiple

occasions and submitted photo into evidence.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale found Case No. 22-27 2891

Chinabox Street to be in violation of Chapter 42-23, North Port City Code for debris

on the property, and imposed a fine of $10 a day with a maximum of $1000 to

commence on April 19, 2022.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale closed Case No. 22-27 2891

Chinabox Street regarding Section. 46-148 City of North Port Code due to

compliance with no further action required.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale closed Case No. 22-27 2891

Chinabox Street regarding Section 59-16(c), North Port City Code due to

compliance with no further action required.

S. Case No

(HLB) TDP-FL LLC, 5339 Inkwood Dr

22-30

Chapter 42-23, North Port City Code

(Debris on this property consisting of portable carport, camping materials,

different types of fencing, trash and other miscellaneous items.)

Chapter 70-21, North Port City Code

(Driving over right of way to access this property.)

Inspector Burton, being duly sworn, noted the property owner is actively clearing the

property and requested a continuance.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale continued Case No. 22-30 5339

Inkwood Drive regarding Chapter 42-23, North Port City Code to the April 28, 2022

Code Enforcement Hearing.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale continued Case No. 22-30 5339

Inkwood Drive regarding Chapter 70-21, North Port City Code to the April 28, 2022

Code Enforcement Hearing.

T. Case No

(JAG) Nathan & Judith A Rosenfeld, 7826 Taplin Ave

Chapter 105.1, Florida Building Code

22-52

(No permit on file for the shed in the rear yard at this property)

Inspector Guilbault, being duly sworn, noted the property owner is actively obtaining a

permit, and he requested a continuance to the May meeting.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale continued Case No. 22-52 7826

Taplin Avenue regarding Chapter 105.1, Florida Building Code to the May 26, 2022

Code Enforcement Hearing.

U. Case No

(WK) Mikhail G Bublik, 3842 Gaskins Cir

Section 45-5A, Unified Land Development Code

(No permit on file for land clearing.)

22-174

Inspector Kiddy, being duly sworn, stated the property was inspected on multiple

occasions, there were an unknown number of trees removed, and submitted one photo

into evidence.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale found Case No. 22-174 3842

Gaskins Circle to be in violation of Section 45-5(a), Unified Land Development

Code for no permit on file for land clearing with an undetermined number of trees

removed, and imposed a fine of $2500.

V. Case No

(HLB) Coelho Investments USA LLC, 3505 Brownwood Ter

Section 45-5A, Unified Land Development Code

(No permit on file for land clearing.)

22-200

Inspector Burton, being duly sworn, noted the permit is in pick up status, and he

requested a continuance.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale continued Case No. 22-200

3505 Brownwood Terrace to the April 28, 2022 Code Enforcement Hearing.

W. Case No

(JAG) Diana Andrade & Michael Andrade, 8050 Porto Chico Ave

Sec. 59-16(f)(4), North Port City Code

22-224

(Camper parked in the city right-of-way.)

Chapter 14-20 Adoption of Florida Building

(No power or water deeming this property unfit for human occupancy, Red

Card posted on 1/21/2022)

Inspector Guilbault, being duly sworn, stated the property was inspected on multiple

occasions, he had no contact with the property owner, the property is presently vacant,

camper has been removed and submitted photos into evidence.

Mr. Kiddy, being duly sworn, noted that City Staff removed animals, remodeling needed

inside of the structure and described the structure as unlivable.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale closed Case No. 22-224 8050

Porto Chico Avenue regarding Section 59-16(f)(4), North Port City Code due to

compliance with no further action required.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale found Case No. 22-224 8050

Porto Chico Avenue to be in violation of Chapter 14-20 Adoption of Florida

Building Code for no power or water deeming this property unfit for human

occupancy and imposed a fine of $250 a day with no maximum to commence on

April 19, 2022.

X. Case No

(JAG) Angela L Johnson, 6837 Beedla St

22-307

Section 105.4.1.1, Florida Building Code

(Expired permit for Land Clear #19-1216; Expired Permit for Culvert Pipe

Installation #19-1380; Expired Permit for Electric on site #19-1381. Please

contact the Building and Permitting department.)

Chapter 42-23, North Port City Code

(Accumulation of debris on property consisting of construction materials,

cinder blocks, outboard boat engine, tarps, scaffolding, lumber etc.

Downed trees and stumps, littering the property)

Sec. 59-16(c), North Port City Code

(Parking vehicles on vacant property next to residence, with no principal

structure to include, an open trailer, a white Ford Pickup, a Generator, as

well as a Large Camper.)

Inspector Guilbault, being duly sworn, stated the property was inspected on multiple

occasions and he had no contact with owners prior to today.

Property owner Angela Johnson, being duly sworn, stated she was ill and was unable to

finish the projects in a timely manner.

Mr. Guilbault requested a continuance.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale continued Case No. 22-307

6837 Beedla Street for Section 105.4.1.1, Florida Building Code to the April 28,2022

Code Enforcement Hearing.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale closed Case No. 22-307 6837

Beedla Street regarding Chapter 42-23, North Port City Code due to compliance

with no further action required.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale closed Case No. 22-307 6837

Beedla Street regarding Section 59-16(c), North Port City Code due to compliance

with no further action required.

Y. Case No

(WK) John A Deblasio & Ute Deblasio, 3102 Rufus Rd

Section 45-5A, Unified Land Development Code

(No permit on file for land clearing.)

22-333

Case No. 22-333 was heard with Case No. 22-340.

Inspector Kiddy, being duly sworn, noted the property owner's attorney could not be in

attendance, and he requested a continuance.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale continued Case No. 22-333

3102 Rufus Road to the April 28, 2022 Code Enforcement Hearing.

Z. Case No

(WK) Aleksandr & Larisa Y Khoroshenko, 3713 Basket St

22-335

Chapter 42-23, North Port City Code

(Accumulation of debris throughout the exterior of the property consisting of

a large amount of burned household items, bricks, wood, metal, loose

trash, construction materials, vehicle parts, miscellaneous Page 2 of 2

household items. All items must be removed from the exterior of house in

front, sides, and rear yard or the city will take action to abate.)

Case No. 22-335 was heard with Case No. 22-342.

Ms. Hale swore in the Russian interpreter to provide accurate interpretations during this

legal proceeding.

Inspector Kiddy, being duly sworn, stated the properties were inspected on multiple

occasions, he had no contact with the property owner, and submitted photos into

evidence.

Property owner Aleksandr Khoroshenko, being duly sworn, stated photos were an

accurate depiction of the properties.

Mr. Raducci, being duly sworn, stated there was no active permit on file for demolition,

after 45 days the City will take action to remove all remaining debris, and will bill Mr.

Khoroshenko.

Mr. Khoroshenko spoke to receiving letters from the City regarding permit status but

could not produce letters for this hearing.

Mr. Toale addressed Code Enforcement's responsibility to produce evidence of a violation

and property owner's responsibility to show why he is not in violation, will treat the

abatement separately and will ensure defendants receive due process.

Mr. Raducci stated if property can come to compliance there will be no further action.

Mr. Khoroshenko agreed to meet with Mr. Kiddy for a walk-through on March 28, 2022 at

10:00 a.m.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale continued Case No. 22-335

3713 Basket Street, to the April 28, 2022 Code Enforcement Hearing, and supports

the City's position that if not compliant by that date, the abatement papers will be

served.

AA. Case No

(WK) John Deblasio & Ute Deblasio, 3087 Seth Rd

Section 45-5A, Unified Land Development Code

(No permit on file for land clearing.)

22-340

Case No. 22-340 was heard with Case No. 22-333.

Inspector Kiddy, being duly sworn, noted the property owner's attorney could not be in

attendance and he requested a continuance.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale continued Case No. 22-340

3087 Seth Road to the April 28, 2022 Code Enforcement Hearing.

AB. Case No

(WK) Aleksandr & Larisa Y Khoroshenko, 3713 Basket St

Sec. 59-16(F)(1), North Port City Code

22-342

(White Car with expired plate, parked in City Right-of-way in front of vacant

lot.)

Sec. 59-16(c), North Port City Code

(Grey Van, unlicensed, parked on vacant lot to the left of the house, which

has no principal structure.)

Sec. 59-16(d), North Port City Code

(Grey car on driveway in disrepair state, missing major components, and

visibly not drivable.)

Section 105.4.1.1, Florida Building Code

(Demo permit on file 21-2970 has expired.)

Case No. 22-342 was heard with Case No. 22-335.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale continued Case No. 22-342

3713 Basket Street regarding Section 59-16(f)(1), North Port City Code to the April

28, 2022 Code Enforcement Hearing.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale closed Case No. 22-342 3713

Basket Street regarding Section 59-16(c), North Port City Code due to compliance

with no further action required.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale closed Case No. 22-342 3713

Basket Street regarding Section 59-16(d), North Port City Code due to compliance

with no further action required.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale continued Case No. 22-342

3713 Basket Street regarding Section 105.4.1.1, Florida Building Code to the April

28, 2022 Code Enforcement Hearing.

AC. Case No

(WK) Mitchell Crosby, 5064 Alametos Ter

22-345

Sec. 59-16(d), North Port City Code

(Vehicle repair, maintenance, and disassembly on property. Prohibited

painting of vehicles being performed multiple times over the past couple

months of which is prohibited on any residential lot.)

Sec. 59-16(i), North Port City Code

(Prohibited vehicle dump truck/truck tractor, and construction equipment

parked on driveway during initial visit.)

Chapter 42-23, North Port City Code

(Accumulation of debris consisting of an engine lift, automotive

parts/equipment, wood posts with wheels, lumber or any other building

materials or equipment left outside not currently in use.)

Sec. 53-122D, Unified Land Development Code

(Evidence of business activity on the premises, (Painting/Repair work)

including the parking and storage of commercial vehicles, material storage,

inordinate vehicular traffic, outside storage. (Business "Resurrection

Gelcoat & Paint Repair, Inc))

Inspector Kiddy, being duly sworn, stated the case is in compliance of all violations, had

contacted the property owner, and due to the repeat nature of prior cases, he requested

that any future repeat violation be fined.

Property owner Mitchell Crosby, being duly sworn, stated he understood the

consequences of future violations and confirmed there was a violation in the past.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale, closed Case No. 22-345 5064

Alametos Terrace, regarding Section 59-16(d), North Port City Code due to

compliance with no further action required.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale, closed Case No. 22-345 5064

Alametos Terrace, regarding Section 59-16(i), North Port City Code due to

compliance with no further action required.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale, closed Case No. 22-345 5064

Alametos Terrace, regarding Chapter 42-23, North Port City Code due to

compliance with no further action required.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale, closed Case No. 22-345 5064

Alametos Terrace, regarding Section 53-122D, Unified Land Development Code due

to compliance with no further action required.

AD. Case No

(JAG) Joshua E Thomas, 5527 Galambos St

Section 45-5A, Unified Land Development Code

(No permit on file for land clearing.)

22-371

Case No. 22-371 was heard with Case No. 22-375.

Inspector Guilbault, being duly sworn, stated the property was inspected multiple

occasions, there was an unknown number of trees removed, and submitted photos into

evidence.

Property owner, Joshua Thomas, being duly sworn, stated the photo is accurate

depiction of the property, agreed the approximate number of trees removed totaled three

for each property, trees still needing to be removed in the footprint of the home, and land

clearing being performed by a previous owner.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale found Case No. 22-371 5527

Galambos Street to be in violation of Section 45-5(a), Unified Land Development

Code for no permit on file for land clearing with an approximate number of trees

removed on this lot totaling three and imposed a fine of $750.

AE. Case No

(JAG) Joshua E Thomas, 5535 Galambos St

Section 45-5A, Unified Land Development Code

(No permit on file for land clearing.)

22-375

Case No. 22-375 was heard with Case No. 22-371.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale found Case No. 22-37 5535

Galambos Street to be in violation of Section 45-5(a), Unified Land Development

Code for no permit on file for land clearing with an approximate number of trees

removed on this lot totaling three and imposed a fine of $750.

Recess was taken from 11:00 a.m. to 11:10 a.m.

AF. Case No

(JAG) Howard E Thomas & Floreliz B Springstun, 5513 Galambos St

Section 45-5A, Unified Land Development Code

(No permit on file for land clearing.)

22-376

Inspector Guilbault, being duly sworn, stated the property was inspected on multiple

occasions, the number of trees removed being undetermined, submitted photos into

evidence, he had contact with the property owner, and noted the previous owner

performed the land clearing.

Joshua Thomas, holding Power of Attorney, being duly sworn, submitted mitigating

circumstances that the land clearing was performed by

a previous owner, had no

objection to photos submitted, and stated the property was purchased last October.

Mr. Golen, being duly sworn, spoke to the current owner being liable for previous

un-permitted changes to property with a civil case in court being the only recourse.

Mr. Raducci, being duly sworn, spoke to a title search done on land with a survey.

Mr. Thomas estimated three trees being removed.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale found Case No. 22-376 5513

Galambos Street to be in violation of Section 45-5(a), Unified Land Development

Code for no permit on file for land clearing and imposed a fine of $750.

AG. Case No

(WK) Leon-Felix Laurent, 3310 Ikola Ave

Section 45-5A, Unified Land Development Code

(No permit on file for land clearing.)

22-459

Inspector Kiddy, being duly sworn, stated the property was inspected on multiple

occasions, an undetermined number of trees being removed, and submitted photos into

evidence.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale found Case No. 22-459 3310

Ikola Avenue to be in violation of Section 45-5(a), Unified Land Development Code

for no permit on file for land clearing with the number of trees removed being

unknown and imposed a fine of $2500.

AH. Case No

(JA) Clementes Construction Inc, 3011 S Cranberry Blvd

Section 45-5A, Unified Land Development Code

(No permit on file for land clearing.)

22-495

Ms. Hale swore in the Spanish interpreter to provide accurate interpretations during this

legal proceeding.

Inspector Ardinger, being duly sworn, stated the property was inspected on multiple

occasions and submitted photos into evidence.

Property owner Clemente Martinez, being duly sworn, stated he was unaware a permit

was required, stopped cutting trees upon receiving the citation, and requested Staff help

in obtaining a permit.

Mr. Toale explained there being no process in North Port for obtaining an "after the fact"

permit for tree removal.

Mr. Martinez had no objection to the photos submitted representing the condition of the

property.

Ms. Ardinger noted that the cleared area of the property was approximately 1/8 of the

property.

Mr. Martinez agreed.

Ms. Ardinger spoke to Sabal Palms counting as protected trees requiring a permit to be

cut and before a tree may be removed and a letter from a certified arborist required

confirming the tree is dead.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale found Case No. 22-495 3011 S

Cranberry Boulevard to e in violation of Section 45-5(a), Unified Land Development

Code for no permit on file for land clearing and assessed a fine of $2000 due to the

property being affected was only 1/8 of the total area.

AI. Case No

(WK) Lotvestors LLC, 4425 Old Wine Rd

Section 45-5A, Unified Land Development Code

(No permit on file for land clearing.)

22-510

Inspector Kiddy, being duly sworn, stated the property was inspected on multiple

occasions, the number of trees removed was unknown, and submitted photos into

evidence.

Property Owner Michael Ferreira, being duly sworn, stated he had no objection to photos

of trees being submitted, had an objection to the possible out-of-date satellite photo, and

submitted most recent aerial photos taken after the fire.

Mr. Toale accepted new photos taken after the fire of 2020 along with other photos.

Mr. Ferreira was unaware there were tenants living on the property, trees cut were already

dead, brush was cleared with weed-wacker, living palm trees were not touched, some

stumps were dead for an undetermined time, and no permit was pulled to cut trees.

Mr. Kiddy did not observe any stumps that were live trees.

Mr. Ferreira stated he has been working with Mr. Kiddy and is determined that the lot will

be cleaned with no further damage being done.

Mr. Kiddy spoke to City Code trees killed by fire still need arborist inspection.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing officer Toale found Case No. 22-510 4425 Old

Wine Road to be in violation of Section 45-5(a), Unified Land Development Code

for no permit on file for land clearing and imposed a fine of $250.

AJ. Case No

(WK) Reinvest Homes LLC, 1309 Nackman Rd

Section 105.4.1.1, Florida Building Code

22-518

(Expired permit for single family home residence)

Inspector Kiddy, being duly sworn, stated the property was inspected on multiple

occasions, he had no contact with the property owner prior to today, and submitted no

photos into evidence.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale found Case No. 22-518 1309

Nackman Road, to be in violation of Section 105.4.1.1, Florida Building Code for

an expired permit for single-family home residence, and imposed a fine of $50 a

day with a maximum of $5000 to commence on April 19, 2022.

9. 2ND HEARING CASES

A. Case No

(JAG) Thomas L Cleary & Ronald L Cleary, 8713 LaBoca Ave

Chapter 42-23, North Port City Code

21-789

(Accumulation of debris throughout the property consisting of refrigerators,

cardboard items, broken down lawnmowers, buckets, and other

miscellaneous items.)

Inspector Guibault, being duly sworn, stated there were no changes to the property, and

requested that the Order be signed and impose the fine.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale found Case No. 21-789 8713

LaBoca Avenue to be in violation of Chapter 42-23, North Port City Code for

accumulation of debris throughout the property, and signed the Order imposing

the fine.

B. Case No

(WK) Shadeenah Bolden, 6740 S Biscayne Dr

21-4060

Chapter 105.1, Florida Building Code

(Digging up City Right-of-way, placing cement, sand, and bricks with no

permit on file for work being performed.)

Inspector Kiddy, being duly sworn, stated the property was inspected on multiple

occasions and submitted photos into evidence.

Dewana Bell, the property owner's sister being duly sworn, stated she no longer lived on

the property.

Mr. Kiddy spoke to the permit issuing requirements and current status of the property.

Ms. Bell spoke to recent pictures of the property.

Mr. Raducci, being duly sworn, addressed permits to be pulled by a contractor with all

subsequent building inspections.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer continued Case No. 21-4060 to the

April 28, 2022 Code Enforcement Hearing with the condition that a permit must be

pulled.

C. Case No

(WK) Millard W Eheart, 4047 Suburban Ln

21-4539

Chapter 42-23, North Port City Code

(Accumulation of debris consisting of Loose trash in front sides and rear of

house, piles of metal on driveway, wood, plastic and other household items

that need to be removed or stored enclosure, also Motor cart in disrepair

on driveway.)

Section 105.4.1.1, Florida Building Code

(Expired permit 17-6437/ INT-COMPLETE CHANGE OUT)

Sec. 59-16(d), North Port City Code

(Disabled vehicle on driveway; RV with flat tires and parts on driveway)

Inspector Kiddy, being duly sworn, stated the property was inspected on multiple

occasions, the violations for Section 105.1.1 Florida Building Code and Section 59-16(d),

North Port City Code were brought into compliance, otherwise there were no changes to

the property and submitted photos into evidence.

Property owner Millard Eheart, being duly sworn, questioned the date of the most recent

inspection.

Mr. Kiddy addressed the overgrowth and debris, items in front were found to be in

compliance, and permits being expired.

Mr. Eheart stated he hired-out the cleanup work and will do a walk-through with a

property standards inspector to determine remaining non-compliant issues.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale continued Case No. 21-4539

4047 Suburban Lane regarding Chapter 42-23, North Port City Code, to the April 24,

2022 Code Enforcement Hearing.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale closed Case No. 21-4539 4707

Suburban

Lane

regarding

Section

105.1.1 Florida

Building

Code

due

compliance with no further action required.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale closed Case No. 21-4539 4047

Suburban Lane regarding Section 59-16(d), North Port City Code due to compliance

with no further action required.

D. Case No

(JA) HPA US1 LLC, 8157 Chesebro Ave

Sec. 1-19, Unified Land Development Code

(Property is fenced with no permit on file.)

21-4579

Inspector Guilbault, being duly sworn, stated there were no changes to the property and

requested the Order be signed imposing a fine.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale found Case No.21-4579 8157

Chesebro Avenue in violation of Section 1-19, Unified Land Development Code for

no permit on file for installing a fence and signed the Order imposing the fine.

E. Case No

(WK) Alexander Rokovets, 4187 Aba Lane

21-4582

Sec. 59-16(f)(4), North Port City Code

(Two (2) Construction open trailers parked in City Right-of-way)

Sec. 59-16(f)(3), North Port City Code

(Damage to swale with tire ruts)

Sec. 59-16(d), North Port City Code

(Disassembled grey car on driveway. Many tires, tools, and parts left in

front side and rear of home.)

Sec. 53-122D, Unified Land Development Code

(Business activity on premises consisting of parking and storing

commercial vehicles, material storage, and inordinate vehicular traffic.)

Chapter 42-23, North Port City Code

(Accumulation of debris consisting of loose trash, and other household

items being stored outside).

Chapter 70-56, North Port City Code

(No visible assigned numbers affixed to residence.)

Section 105.4.1.1, Florida Building Code

(Expired permit 14-4026, for detached garage on property)

Sec. 53-239(I)(12), Home Occupations/Special Circumstances Unified

Land Development Code

(Outside storage of materials used in connection with business, such as

construction equipment, materials used in construction and miscellaneous

parts.)

Inspector Kiddy, being duly sworn, noted the status of each violation and submitted

photos into evidence.

Property owner Alexander Rokovets, being duly sworn, stated he applied for a permit prior

to the meeting and submitted photos into evidence.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale closed Case No. 21-4582 4187

Aba Lane Section 59-16(f)(4), North Port City Code due to compliance with no

further action required.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale closed Case No. 21-4582 4187

Aba Lane Section 59-16(f)(3), North Port City Code due to compliance with no

further action required.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale closed Case No. 21-4582 4187

Aba Lane Section 59-16(d), North Port City Code due to compliance with no further

action required.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale continued Case No. 21-4582

4187 Aba Lane Section 53-122(d), Unified Land Development Code to the April 28

Code Enforcement Hearing.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale closed Case No. 21-4582 4187

Aba Lane Chapter 42-23, North Port City Code due to compliance with no further

action required.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale closed Case No. 21-4582 4187

Aba Lane Chapter 70-56, North Port City Code due to compliance with no further

action required.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale continued Case No. 21-4582

4187 Aba Lane Section 105.4.1.1, Florida Building Code to the April 28, 2022 Code

Enforcement Hearing.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale continued Case No. 21-4582

4187 Aba Lane Section 53-239(I)(12), Unified Land Development Code to the April

28, 2022 Code Enforcement Hearing.

F. Case No

(WK) Jesse Demello, 2518 Ridgewood Dr

21-4637

Section 42-24(a)(5) North Port City Code

(Accumulation of debris in City Right-of-way consisting of tree trunks,

branches, and yard waste all along the City Right-of-way area in multiple

piles. Loose trash, wood, cardboard, oil containers, and miscellaneous

household items scattered about City Right-of-way as well.)

Inspector Kiddy, being duly sworn, stated the property was inspected on numerous

occasions, there were changes in property since last month, and submitted photos into

evidence.

Property owner Jesse Demello, being duly sworn, stated he anticipated debris cleanup

could be finished by this weekend.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale continued Case No. 21-4637

2518 Ridgewood Drive to the April 2, 2022 Code Enforcement Hearing.

G. Case No

(HLB) David Lloyd Wells & Vanessa Wells, 5258 Butterfly Ln

Chapter 42-23, North Port City Code

21-4645

(Homeowner has a dilapidated wooden fence that is falling apart must be

repaired or removed. Also, there is accumulation of debris in the back yard

consisting of broken cabinets or dressers.)

Section 42-24(a)(5) North Port City Code

(Accumulation of debris in the City Right-of-Way consisting of yard waste)

Chapter 105.1, Florida Building Code

(No permit on file for Shed located on property)

Inspector Burton, being duly sworn, stated there were no changes in the property and

requested the Order be signed imposing the fine.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale found Case No. 21-4645 5258

Butterfly Lane to be in violation of Chapter 42-23, North Port City Code for a

dilapidated wooden fence and an accumulation of debris in the back, and will sign

the Order imposing the fine.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale found Case No. 21-4645 5258

Butterfly Lane to be in violation of Section 42-24(a)(5) North Port City Code for

debris in the City right-of-way and will sign the Order imposing the fine.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale found Case No. 21-4645 5258

Butterfly Lane to be in violation of Chapter 105.1, Florida Building Code for no

permit on file for shed and will sign the Order imposing the fine.

H. Case No

(WK) Jericho June Minnix, 2518 Margaret Ln

21-4892

Chapter 42-23, North Port City Code

(Accumulation of debris consisting of loose trash in front of home,

cardboard and household items spilling out from garage. Also, there are

stacks of bricks on front yard)

Chapter 62-50, North Port City Code

(Solid Waste Containers improperly stored at the street outside the time

frame permissible by City Code. Pick up for this area is on Friday.

Violation observed on a Monday.)

Inspector Kiddy, being duly sworn, reported no changes in property, property being

inspected on multiple occasions, stated pictures were submitted into evidence at the first

hearing, and he requested the Order be signed imposing the fine.

Property owner Jericho June Minnix, being duly sworn, stated that most of the debris is

gone, she was unable to attend the first hearing due to family illness, can remove

remaining debris this week and will inform Mr. Kiddy when completed.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale continued Case No. 21-4892

2518 Margaret Lane, regarding Chapter 42-23, North Port City Code to the April 21,

2022 Code Enforcement Hearing.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale, continued Case No. 21-4892

2518 Margaret Lane, regarding Chapter 62-50, North Port City Code to the April 21,

2022 Code Enforcement Hearing.

Case No

21-4975

(WK) CSMA BLT LLC, 3163 Monday Ter

Section 42-24(a)(5) North Port City Code

(Accumulation of debris consisting of cardboard, plastic totes, fish tank,

pallets in City Right-of-way across the street from home, with no bulk pick

up scheduled.)

Chapter 42-23, North Port City Code

(Accumulation of debris consisting of cardboard in front yard, driveway up

to front door, vehicle bumpers/parts on front yard, as well as household

items, plastic shelving on driveway and dolly)

Chapter 62-50, North Port City Code

(Solid Waste Containers improperly stored in front of house, left of

driveway)

Chapter 34-23, North Port City Code

(Running a business in home without a Business Tax Receipt)

Section 53-122, Unified Land Development Code

(Evidence of business being ran from residential.)

Inspector Kiddy, being duly sworn, noted Section 42-24(a)(5) North Port City Code being

in compliance, Section 42-23, North Port City Code remaining in compliance, Chapter

62-50, North Port City Code remaining in violation, Chapter 34-23, North Port City Code

remaining in violation, and Section 53-122, Unified Land Development Code being in

compliance.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale closed Case No. 21-4645 53163

Monday Terrace regarding Section 42-24(a)(5) North Port City Code due to

compliance with no further action required.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale found Case No. 21-4645 53163

Monday Terrace to be in violation of Chapter 42-23, North Port City Code for

accumulation of debris in front yard, and imposed

maximum of $1000 to commence on April 19, 2022.

a fine of $10 a day with a

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale found Case No. 21-4645 53163

Monday Terrace to be in violation of Chapter 62-50, North Port City Code for solid

waste containers in front of house and imposed a fine of $10 a day with a maximum

of $1000 to commence on April 19, 2022.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale found Case No. 21-4645 53163

Monday Terrace to be in violation of Chapter 34-23, North Port City Code for

running a business in home without a Business Tax Receipt, and imposed a fine of

$10 a day with a maximum of $1000 to commence on April 19, 2022.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale closed Case No. 21-4645 3163

Monday Terrace regarding Section 53-122, Unified Land Development Code, due to

compliance with no further action required.

10. PUBLIC HEARING - POLICE DEPARTMENT

22-2312

Case

#22-009469 Trespass

Appeal

Ivan

Shkrobut,

12200 San

Servando Avenue, North Port, FL 34287 (Warm Mineral Springs).

Trespasser Ivan Shkrobut was not present.

Mr. Golen, representing the North Port Police Department, being duly sworn, presented

forms requesting this appeal and noted that the individual refused to leave when so

requested, and therefore police were called.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale, Case #22-009469 Trespass

Appeal, noted the offender was not present and denied the appeal.

22-2342

Case # 22-010799 Trespass Appeal -- Michael Ramirez -- 8270 Lombra

Avenue, North Port, FL 34286 (Veterans Park)

Ms. Hale swore in Officer Nicholas Mamalis, who will provide testimony.

Michael Ramirez, being duly sworn, requested to be shown where the trespass had taken

place and had nothing more to say.

Mr. Golen, being duly sworn, requested that Officer Mamalis provide his testimony.

Officer Mamalis, being duly sworn, provided an account of issuing the trespass to Mr.

Ramirez and the subsequent Police Incident Report documenting the associated violation

of City Ordinance 46-1(12) drinking on public property, and is an accurate depiction of

what happened.

Mr. Ramirez had no questions for the officer who issued the citation.

Based on evidence presented, Hearing Officer Toale, Case #22-010799 Trespass

Appeal, noted the trespass warning was issued properly and denied the appeal.

11. GENERAL BUSINESS

There was no general business.

12. PUBLIC COMMENT

There was no public comment.